Escândalo num concurso universitário !

Adenda ao post http://tempoderecordar-edmartinho.blogspot.pt/2012/05/escandalo-num-concurso-universitario.html

Estive agora a ler com a devida atenção o Edital de abertura do concurso (Edital N.º 832/ 2011 da Reitoria da Universidade de Lisboa, publicado no Diário da República, 2.ª série, N.º 162, de 24 de Agosto de 2011) e cheguei à conclusão de que o escândalo é ainda maior do que o denunciado anteriormente!

Transcrevo a seguir as partes do Edital de abertura do concurso que interessam para o fim em vista:

«Doutor António Sampaio da Nóvoa, Reitor da Universidade de Lisboa:

Faz saber que, (…) se encontra aberto concurso para recrutamento de um posto de trabalho de Professor Catedrático, do Departamento de Geologia, na área científica de Geologia, especialidade de Geodinâmica Externa (…).

II — Critérios de avaliação em mérito absoluto

Encontrando -se as candidaturas devidamente instruídas de acordo com o ponto I [Requisitos de admissão] do presente edital, a admissão em mérito absoluto dos candidatos dependerá da posse de currículo global que o júri considere revestir mérito científico compatível com a área ou áreas disciplinares para que foi aberto o concurso.»

Em resumo:

(1) O concurso foi aberto na área científica de Geologia.

(2) O Júri entendeu que o “currículo global” do candidato Fernando Ornelas Marques não tinha mérito científico compatível com a área para que foi aberto o concurso, isto é, a área de Geologia!

(3) Se isto não constitui um escândalo, não sei o que possa ser considerado escandaloso…

Para que o leitor possa ajuizar por si a qualidade da decisão do Júri, deixo à sua consideração a lista ISI das publicações do candidato entre 2003 (ano da agregação) e 2011 (ano do concurso):


Title: Microstructural and mechanical effects of strong fine-grained muscovite in soft halite matrix: Shear strain localization in torsion

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Burlini, L.; Burg, J. P.

Source: Journal of Geophysical Research-Solid Earth Volume: 116 Published: 2011

  

Title: Microstructure and mechanical properties of halite/coarse muscovite synthetic aggregates deformed in torsion

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Burlini, L.; Burg, J. -P.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 33 Issue: 4 Pages: 624-632 Published: APR 2011

Title: Numerical analysis of subduction initiation risk along the Atlantic American passive margins

Author(s): Nikolaeva, Ksenia; Gerya, Taras V.; Marques, Fernando O.

Source: Geology Volume: 39 Issue: 5 Pages: 463-466 Published: 2011

Title: Comment on "Deep structure, recent deformation and analog modeling of the Gulf of Cadiz accretionary wedge: Implications for the 1755 Lisbon earthquake", by Gutscher et al. 2009

Author(s): Marques, F. O.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 485 Issue: 1-4 Pages: 327-329 Published: 2010

Title: Dynamic unfolding of multilayers: 2D numerical approach and application to turbidites in SW Portugal

Author(s): Lechmann, S. M.; Schmalholz, S. M.; Burg, J. P.; et al.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 494 Issue: 1-2 Pages: 64-74 Published: 2010

Title: Fluid-assisted particulate flow of turbidites at very low temperature: A key to tight folding in a submarine Variscan foreland basin of SW Europe

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Burg, J. P.; Lechmann, S. M.; et al.

Source: Tectonics Volume: 29 Published: 2010

Title: Rheology and microstructure of synthetic halite/calcite porphyritic aggregates in torsion

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Burlini, L.; Burg, J. P.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 32 Issue: 3 Pages: 342-349 Published: 2010

Title: Subduction initiation at passive margins: Numerical modeling

Author(s): Nikolaeva, K; Gerya, TV; Marques, FO

Source: Journal of Geophysical Research-Solid Earth Volume: 115 Published: MAR 10 2010

Title: Technical note on the strength of copper versus polymer jackets in torsion tests on halite up to 300 degrees C

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Burlini, L.; Armann, M.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 490 Issue: 1-2 Pages: 55-59 Published: 2010

Title: Thick dyke emplacement and internal flow: A structural and magnetic fabric study of the deep-seated dolerite dyke of Foum Zguid (southern Morocco)

Author(s): Silva, Pedro F.; Marques, Fernando O.; Henry, Bernard; et al.

Source: Journal of Geophysical Research-Solid Earth Volume: 115 Published: 2010

Title: A thin elastic core can control large-scale patterns of lithosphere shortening

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Podladchikov, Y. Y.

Source: Earth and Planetary Science Letters Volume: 277 Issue: 1-2 Pages: 80-85 Published: 2009

  

Title: Reply to discussion by GI Alsop and RE Holdsworth of "Sheath fold development with viscosity contrast: analogue experiments in bulk simple shear" by Marques et al., Journal of Structural Geology, 30, 1348-1353

Author(s): Marques, Fernando O.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 31 Issue: 2 Pages: 218-219 Published: 2009

  

Title: Geodynamic evolution of the SW Variscides: Orogenic collapse shown by new tectonometamorphic and isotopic data from western Ossa-Morena Zone, SW Iberia

Author(s): Rosas, F. M.; Marques, F. O.; Ballevre, M.; et al.

Source: Tectonics Volume: 27 Issue: 6 Published: 2008

Title: Magma flow, exsolution processes and rock metasomatism in the Great Messejana-Plasencia dyke (Iberian Peninsula)

Author(s): Silva, Pedro F.; Henry, Bernard; Marques, Fernando O.; et al.

Source: Geophysical Journal International Volume: 175 Issue: 2 Pages: 806-824 Published: 2008

Title: Multi-stage evolution of a sub-aerial volcanic ridge over the last 1.3 Myr: S. Jorge Island, Azores Triple Junction

Author(s): Hildenbrand, Anthony; Madureira, Pedro; Marques, Fernando Ornelas; et al.

Source: Earth and Planetary Science Letters Volume: 273 Issue: 3-4 Pages: 289-298 Published: 2008

Title: Normal fault inversion by orthogonal compression: Sandbox experiments with weak faults

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Nogueira, C. R.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 30 Issue: 6 Pages: 761-766 Published: 2008

Title: Rigid inclusions rotate in geologic materials as shown by torsion experiments

Author(s): Marques, FO; Burlini, L

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 30 Issue: 11 Pages: 1368-1371 Published: NOV 2008

Title: Sheath fold development with viscosity contrast: Analogue experiments in bulk simple shear

Author(s): Marques, Fernando O.; Guerreiro, Susana M.; Fernandes, Ana R.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 30 Issue: 11 Pages: 1348-1353 Published: 2008

Title: Thrust initiation and propagation during shortening of a 2-layer model lithosphere

Author(s): Marques, Femando O.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 30 Issue: 1 Pages: 29-38 Published: 2008

Title: Applications of inclusion behaviour models to a major shear zone system: The Nordfjord-Sogn Detachment Zone in western Norway

Author(s): Marques, Fernando O.; Schmid, Daniel W.; Andersen, Torgeir B.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 29 Issue: 10 Pages: 1622-1631 Published: 2007

Title: Physical models of rifting and transform faulting, due to ridge push in a wedge-shaped oceanic lithosphere

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Cobbold, P. R.; Lourenco, N.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 443 Issue: 1-2 Pages: 37-52 Published: 2007

Title: Comment on "Numerical models of flow patterns around a rigid inclusion in a viscous matrix undergoing simple shear: implications of model parameters and boundary conditions" by N. Mandal, S.K. Samanta and C. Chakraborty Journal of Structural Geology  ...

Author(s): Marques, Fernando O.; Taborda, Rui; Bose, Santanu

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 28 Issue: 7 Pages: 1371-1374 Published: 2006

Title: Effects of topography on the curvature of fold-and-thrust belts during shortening of a 2-layer model of continental lithosphere

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Cobbold, P. R.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 415 Issue: 1-4 Pages: 65-80 Published: 2006

Title: Paleomagnetic study of the Great Foum Zguid dyke (southern Morocco): A positive contact test related to metasomatic processes

Author(s): Silva, P. F.; Henry, B.; Marques, F. O.; et al.

Source: Geophysical Research Letters Volume: 33 Issue: 21 Published: 2006

  

Title: Riedel-shear control on the development of pennant veins: Field example and analogue modelling

Author(s): Coelho, S; Passchier, C; Marques, F

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 28 Issue: 9 Pages: 1658-1669 Published: 2006

Title: Variation of magnetic properties in sedimentary rocks hosting the Foum Zguid dyke (southern Morocco): Combined effects of re-crystallization and Fe-metasomatism

Author(s): Silva, P. F.; Henry, B.; Marques, F. O.; et al.

Source: Earth and Planetary Science Letters Volume: 241 Issue: 3-4 Pages: 978-992 Published: 2006

Title: 2D rotation of rigid inclusions in confined bulk simple shear flow: a numerical study

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Taborda, R. M.; Antunes, J. V.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 27 Issue: 12 Pages: 2171-2180 Published: 2005

Title: Effects of confinement on matrix flow around a rigid inclusion in viscous simple shear: insights from analogue and numerical modelling

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Taborda, R.; Bose, S.; et al.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 27 Issue: 3 Pages: 379-396 Published: 2005

Title: Influence of a low-viscosity layer between rigid inclusion and viscous matrix on inclusion rotation and matrix flow: A numerical study

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Taborda, R.; Antunes, J.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 407 Issue: 1-2 Pages: 101-115 Published: 2005

Title: The effectiveness of "clay" liners as basal isolation of landfills: a case study

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Marques, Fmsf; Mateus, A.; et al.

Source: Environmental Geology Volume: 47 Issue: 8 Pages: 1128-1137 Published: 2005

Title: 2-D rotation behavior of a rigid ellipse in confined viscous simple shear: numerical experiments using FEM

Author(s): Taborda, R.; Antunes, J.; Marques, F. O.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 379 Issue: 1-4 Pages: 127-137 Published: 2004

Title: Controls on the geometry of tails around rigid circular inclusions: insights from analogue modelling in simple shear

Author(s): Bose, S.; Marques, F. O.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 26 Issue: 12 Pages: 2145-2156 Published: 2004

Title: Folding of a finite length power law layer

Author(s): Schmid, D. W.; Podladchikov, Y. Y.; Marques, F. O.

Source: Journal of Geophysical Research-Solid Earth Volume: 109 Issue: B3 Published: 2004

Title: Granite fracturing and incipient pollution beneath a recent landfill facility as detected by geoelectrical surveys

Author(s): Mota, R.; Santos, F. A. M.; Mateus, A.; et al.

Source: Journal of Applied Geophysics Volume: 57 Issue: 1 Pages: 11-22 Published: 2004

Title: Influence of a permanent low-friction boundary on rotation and flow in rigid inclusion/viscous matrix systems from an analogue perspective

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Bose, S.

Source: Tectonophysics Volume: 382 Issue: 3-4 Pages: 229-245 Published: 2004

Title: Preliminary results of a study of magnetic properties in the Foum-Zguid dyke (Morocco)

Author(s): Silva, P. F.; Marques, F. O.; Henry, B.; et al.

Source: Physics and Chemistry of the Earth Volume: 29 Issue: 13-14 Pages: 909-920 Published: 2004

Title: 2-D shape preferred orientations of rigid particles in transtensional viscous flow

Author(s): Marques, F. O.; Coelho, S.

Source: Journal of Structural Geology Volume: 25 Issue: 6 Pages: 841-854 Published: 2003

Who cares?